🦐 Roundup: Seafood Restaurants of Martha's Vineyard
🦐 Roundup: Seafood Restaurants of Martha's Vineyard
MVacay picks for each town, seafood markets and local facts to know
The wonderful thing about Martha’s Vineyard is that almost all restaurants are seafood restaurants. Given the proximity to fresh seafood, you can find some kind of fish almost every place you go. There are not “seafood only” restaurants -even the most seafood-forward offer incredible options for non-fish eaters as well.
Martha’s Vineyard is known most for its hot lobster rolls, clam chowder, and local oysters. Another regional specialty at to-go spots are “stuffies” or stuffed quahogs.
Below we’ve listed our personal picks, organized by town. Every restaurant on here we’ve recommended is from our personal experience and none are sponsored.
Oak Bluffs
MVacay Favorites
Best Lunch: Lookout Tavern: Known for hot lobster rolls, fried clams, and a variety of seafood with views of Oak Bluffs.
Best Fried Seafood: Giordano's: A family-owned establishment offering Italian cuisine and seafood, with a takeout window offering fried options.
Family-Friendly: Coop De Ville: A casual spot famous for its fried seafood and outdoor seating.
Best Date Night: Sweet Life Cafe: Offers a refined dining experience with a variety of seafood options.
Best View: Nancy's: A popular spot known for its seafood and harbor views.
Best for Groups: Noman's: A lively, group friendly outdoor option with a diverse menu.
Best Sushi: Mikado Asian Bistro offers a variety of Asian cuisine options, including sushi.
More Options to Explore
Chef Deon's Kitchen / Red Cat Kitchen / Jimmy Seas / MV Chowder Company / Sand Bar & Grille / Lobsterville Bar & Grill / Eleven Circuit / Offshore Ale
Edgartown
MVacay Favorites
Best Lunch: 19 Raw Oyster Bar: Complex flavors and a perfect place to stop during to break up some shopping downtown.
Best Date Night: Covington: Offers locally-sourced seafood in a relaxed, stylish atmosphere.
Best View: The Seafood Shanty: Casual, boasts fantastic views and a wide range of seafood dishes.
Best Fried Seafood: Quarterdeck: a take-out window
Best To-Go: The Fish House: A to-go option known for locally-sourced seafood and Poke Bowls
Best For Groups: Atlantic: Offers a modern take on classic seafood dishes with a waterfront setting.
Best Sushi: Pelican Club: Known for its upscale sushi offerings and sophisticated ambiance.
More Options to Explore
The Wharf / Square Rigger / Rockfish / Port Hunter / Town Bar and Grill / The Newes From America / The Dunes / Lucky Hank’s / L’etoile / Detente / Chesca’s / Bettini / Alchemy / Atria / The Terrace / Katama General Store
Vineyard Haven
MVacay Favorites
Best Date Night: Beach Road Restaurant: Known for its refined casual dining experience, showcasing fresh and seasonal ingredients.
Best View: The Black Dog Tavern: Comfortable, local seafood dishes, conveniently located and an impressive view of Vineyard Haven Harbor.
Best Fried Seafood: John’s Fish Market: A traditional fish market offering a variety of fresh seafood, known for its quality and variety.
Family-Friendly: Fish MV: A local favorite known for its fresh, locally sourced seafood and a variety of prepared dishes.
Best To-Go: The Net Result: A popular market and take-out spot renowned for its wide selection of fresh seafood, including sushi and cooked seafood specialties.
Best Sushi: Mikado Asian Bistro: Offers a unique blend of Asian cuisine, including sushi
More Options to Explore
Salvatore’s Ristorante / The Attic / Garde East
Up-Island
MVacay Favorites
Remember that there are hard alcohol restrictions in Chilmark and Aquinnah if you want to BYOB.
Best View: The Outermost Inn: Located in Aquinnah, offering a unique dining experience with breathtaking views.
Best Date Night: Home Port: new ownership revamped the menu making it special-occasion worthy.
Best For Groups: State Road Restaurant: Offers modern American cuisine featuring local seafood and ingredients.
Best To Go: Menemsha Fish Market: our favorite chowder to grab before a sunset
More Options to Explore
Larsen’s Fish Market / Woods Restaurant at Lambert's Cove Inn / Chilmark Tavern
Seafood Markets with Raw Fish To-Go
Fun Fact: Martha’s Vineyard Seafood Collaborative focuses on supporting local fishermen by providing a direct market for their sustainably caught seafood, thereby promoting the community's economic resilience and environmental stewardship. This organization is a huge contributor to the excellent seafood you’ll find at restaurants!
Quick Reference
If this list overwhelms you or you have a unique request, send us a message and we’re happy to help guide you to the perfect fit for you! Also check out associated articles about the following: