🥪 26 meals for $20 or under on Martha's Vineyard
as consolidated by locals in 2026!
Affordable meals on MV still exist, you just have to know what to order! I crowdsourced real orders from locals and spot-checked the prices. Today I have 26 options for you - all under $20!
7a: Liz Lemon sandwich ($17)
Aquila at the Y: Rice bowls ($13)
The Atlantic: Tomato bisque with grilled cheese ($16)
The Attic: Poutine fries (half off during happy hour, ~$12) ⭐️
The Barn: Brussel & kale salad, daily specials ($18) ⭐️
Black Sheep: Cracklebread daily special (under $20)
Catboat: Falafel bowl ($16)
Coop de Ville: 5 wings + fries ($14)
Cozy Corner Café: Avocado toast ($14)
Edgartown Pizza: Chicken Caesar wrap ($14)
Fat Ronnie’s: Quarter-pound hot dog + fries (under $20)
Honorary Tavern @ VFW: Fish sandwich + fries ($15) ⭐️
MV Food Truck: smoked beef brisket sandwich (~$18)
Maker Café: Chicken Pesto Hoagie with side salad ($18)
Menemsha Fish Market: Fish sandwich ($15)
Morning Glory Farm: Soup + roll; chicken enchiladas ($15)
Mo’s: Veggie Italian; daily specials (under $20) ⭐️
Plane View: Turkey Tuesdays (under $20)
Pocket Dogs: Hot dog ($7)
Rocco’s: Plain cheese pizza (under $20)
Rockfish: Shrimp tacos ($20)
Scottish Bakehouse: Cuban pork plate ($20)
Sharky’s: BBQ pork nachos ($18)
Tigerhawk: Fried chicken sandwich ($16)
Winstons: Meatball sub ($14); garlic chicken dinner ($18) ⭐️
Woodlands: Chicken club ($12)
I tried to find options beyond just burgers & hot dogs! A star shows that locals recommended it as the greatest value (more than 20x each!⭐️) Honorable mentions - the salad bar at Cronigs and daily specials at the Hospital. Prices confirmed Feb 2026, menus change seasonally!
